rt-simulated-referee

Simulated Referee (rt-simulated-referee)

Run the substantive gauntlet before a real referee does. Full protocol + a worked example:

[shared-resources/submission-readiness/simulated-referee.md](../../../shared-resources/submission-readiness/simulated-referee.md).

When to trigger

• After rt-submission-readiness clears the mechanical bar.
• When the author wants to know the decisive objection before submitting.

Calibrate first (this is what makes it realistic)

Pull the venue's bar from the target pack, not generic intuition: acceptance/desk-reject

reality + mechanics from resources/official-source-map.md; what this venue's referees

attack from *-referee-strategy + the shared

[reviewer-objection-checklist](../../../shared-resources/empirical-methods/reviewer-objection-checklist.md);

the fit/identification/robustness bar from the pack's skills. Set strictness to the

venue's selectivity.

Protocol

1. AE desk-screen — fit, general interest, fatal flaws → desk-reject risk; stop if a clear desk reject.
2. Independent referees (distinct lenses: identification skeptic · contribution/fit ·

robustness/reproducibility) each write a structured report.

1. Adversarial verification — every major concern must be **real + specific +

addressable** or be downgraded.

1. AE synthesis — one decision band (reject / major / minor / lean-accept) + the 1–3

decisive issues.

1. Skill-mapped fix list — each decisive issue → the pack skill (and its execution

bridge) that fixes it.

Orchestration

Spawn one subagent per role with the same manuscript + the calibrated venue bar; collect

independent reports; a final AE-synthesis agent. Distinct lenses + independence catch more

than a single read.

Hard rules

1. Calibrate from the pack + source-map, never generic.
2. Verify before reporting (real / specific / addressable).
3. Map every decisive issue to a skill + execution bridge.
4. It's a rehearsal — output a decision band and the decisive issues, never a fake accept probability.

Output format

【Venue】… (calibrated)
【Desk-screen】send out / desk reject — reason; risk low/med/high
【Decision band】reject / major / minor / lean-accept
【Decisive issues (1–3)】each with owning pack skill + concrete fix
【Author action plan】ordered; tie each to a skill + tool

Next: address the decisive issues, then rt-response-to-referees for a real R&R.