en-agrienv-journal-workflow

Agriculture & environment journal workflow (en-agrienv-journal-workflow)

Purpose

This is the routing skill for the agriculture-and-environment bundle. It does not

replace a single-journal profile; it first classifies the manuscript by **sub-field,

contribution type, and evidence shape**, then routes into the matching per-journal

skill for fit and re-framing. It is a sibling to en-natsci-journal-workflow

(natural science) and en-engtech-journal-workflow (engineering).

Ask four things first

1. Sub-field: crop/agronomy, plant biology, soil science, food science,

ecosystem/environmental science, pollution/health, climate/atmosphere, hydrology/water,

ocean/limnology, or solid-earth geoscience?

1. Contribution type: a mechanism, a field/management result, a synthesis/review,

a model or projection, a new dataset/data product, or a methods/measurement advance?

1. Evidence shape: controlled field trial, glasshouse/lab assay, observational or

monitoring survey, remote sensing, long-term record, process/earth-system model, or

a documented public dataset?

1. Audience breadth: broad significance (a Nature Portfolio title), a whole

sub-field (a society flagship), or a specialist community?

Pre-routing evidence gates

Before naming a journal, classify the manuscript through these gates. A weak gate

does not always mean "do not submit"; it usually means route down to a specialist

venue, reframe the claim, or fix the evidence before testing a higher-prestige

venue.

| Gate | Pass signal | If weak |

|---|---|---|

| Contribution | A mechanism, management implication, method, projection, or dataset that transfers beyond the study site | Reframe as a local case study, technical note, or specialist-field result |

| Evidence strength | Replicated sites/seasons/systems, transparent uncertainty, and controls matched to the claim | Do not route to broad Nature/society flagships; strengthen replication first |

| Scale match | Claim scale matches the evidence scale: plot, field, landscape, regional, global, or dataset | Narrow the title/abstract and select a venue that accepts the actual scale |

| Data/code readiness | Data, code, model configuration, and metadata can be deposited or shared under field norms | Treat deposition as a blocker for ESSD, earth-system, hydrology, and reuse claims |

| Compliance | Permits, ethics, biosafety, field-site permissions, and competing-interest disclosures are known | Pause final routing until the single-journal checklist can verify requirements |

Evidence-shape escalation

• Single site-year field trial: usually specialist agronomy/crop venue; do not

pitch as general food-security evidence without multi-site or mechanistic support.

• Multi-site or multi-season field trial: can support field flagship routing if

management implications and uncertainty are explicit.

• Lab/glasshouse mechanism: plant or soil mechanism venues; needs field or

ecological validation before claiming landscape or management impact.

• Remote sensing / monitoring survey: route by validation and generalizability;

benchmark against independent observations and document processing code.

• Process or earth-system model: route by the model contribution, sensitivity

analysis, and reproducibility package, not only by the application region.

• Dataset/data product: earth-system-science-data only when the dataset itself

is the product, has persistent identifiers, rich metadata, and a public archive.

Quick routing

| Manuscript signature | Prefer skill |

|---|---|

| Food-systems advance with broad significance | nature-food |

| Plant-science advance, broad and high-impact | nature-plants |

| Fundamental plant biology / physiology / ecology | new-phytologist / the-plant-journal |

| Authoritative plant-biology review | annual-review-of-plant-biology |

| Crop yield, agronomy, cropping-system field research | field-crops-research / agronomy-for-sustainable-development |

| Agroecosystem nutrient/GHG/biodiversity at field-to-landscape scale | agriculture-ecosystems-and-environment |

| Soil biology, biogeochemistry, soil carbon/microbiome | soil-biology-and-biochemistry |

| Food chemistry / composition / safety | food-chemistry |

| Food-technology trends and synthesis | trends-in-food-science-and-technology |

| Climate-change impacts on ecosystems/biota | global-change-biology |

| Human-exposure environmental health | environment-international / environmental-health-perspectives |

| Sustainability, circular economy, cleaner production | journal-of-cleaner-production / resources-conservation-and-recycling |

| Authoritative environment & resources review | annual-review-of-environment-and-resources |

| Environmental contamination / ecotoxicology | environmental-pollution |

| Broad earth/environment advance, OA | communications-earth-and-environment |

| Climate dynamics / variability | journal-of-climate |

| New, documented public dataset | earth-system-science-data |

| Catchment / surface / groundwater hydrology | journal-of-hydrology / water-resources-research |

| Solid-earth, geochemistry, planetary-scale processes | earth-and-planetary-science-letters / geology |

| Carbon/nutrient cycling, biogeochemistry | global-biogeochemical-cycles |

| Land–atmosphere flux / agro-meteorology | agricultural-and-forest-meteorology |

| Forest ecology and management | forest-ecology-and-management |

| Aquatic / freshwater / ocean ecology and limnology | limnology-and-oceanography |

| Meteorological-society review / community article | bulletin-of-the-american-meteorological-society |

Sibling-journal disambiguation

| Confusable targets | Decision rule |

|---|---|

| nature-food vs field-crops-research | Nature Food wants food-systems significance and transdisciplinary reach; FCR wants a rigorous crop/agronomy field result. |

| new-phytologist vs the-plant-journal | New Phytologist favors plant ecology/physiology/interactions breadth; The Plant Journal favors molecular/cellular plant biology with mechanism. Re-check current scopes. |

| journal-of-hydrology vs water-resources-research | WRR (AGU) favors fundamental water-science methodology/theory; Journal of Hydrology spans process, observational, and applied hydrology more broadly. |

| agriculture-ecosystems-and-environment vs soil-biology-and-biochemistry | AEE emphasizes field-to-landscape agroecosystem outcomes; SBB emphasizes soil-process mechanism and soil biota. |

| global-change-biology vs agriculture-ecosystems-and-environment | GCB needs a global-change framing and biological response; AEE needs an agroecosystem-management framing. |

| Nature Portfolio (nature-food/nature-plants/communications-earth-and-environment) vs society flagships | Nature titles need broad significance and framing; a complete sub-field result routes to the society/specialist journal. |

| earth-system-science-data vs an analysis journal | ESSD is for the dataset itself (documented, publicly deposited with a DOI); the scientific analysis of that data belongs in an analysis journal. |

| environment-international / environmental-health-perspectives vs pollution journals | Human-exposure or health-risk inference routes to the health journals; contaminant behavior, remediation, or ecotoxicology routes to the pollution/environmental-process venues. |

| journal-of-climate vs agricultural-and-forest-meteorology | Climate dynamics and variability route to Journal of Climate; land-atmosphere fluxes, crop/forest microclimate, and agro-meteorological applications route to AFM. |

| global-biogeochemical-cycles vs global-change-biology | Element cycles, fluxes, and earth-system budgets route to GBC; organismal, ecosystem, or biological responses to global change route to GCB. |

| resources-conservation-and-recycling vs journal-of-cleaner-production | Circular-material-flow and recycling systems route to RCR; cleaner production, industrial sustainability, and management interventions route to JCP. |

Decision rules

• Name the advance, not the site. "We measured X at our site" is not a

contribution unless it yields a generalizable mechanism, management result,

projection, or dataset.

• Field evidence discipline. Field/observational claims need adequate replication,

controls, and uncertainty; a single site-year or unreplicated trial is a common reject

at the agronomy and ecology venues.

• Data deposition is a gate, not a nicety. Earth-science and environmental venues

increasingly mandate FAIR data/code deposition; data journals (ESSD) require the public

dataset itself. Sort this before submission.

• Review vs. primary. Annual Review titles and the synthesis-leaning venues are

largely invited/scoped — do not route an unsolicited primary-data paper there without

checking scope.

• Scale and framing. Plot/lab, field, landscape, regional, and global results route

to different venues; match the claim's scale to the journal's audience.

• Health, policy, and management claims need the right endpoint. Do not route

a contaminant-detection paper as environmental health unless exposure/outcome

inference is actually measured; do not route a sustainability paper as policy unless

a decision, intervention, or system boundary is specified.

• Always enter the single-journal skill's official-submission checklist before

submitting; never rely on a stale template.

Handoff protocol

After routing, hand off only the minimum needed context to the single-journal skill:

• the strongest claim the evidence can honestly support;
• the rejected broader claim, if any, and why it was narrowed;
• the evidence shape and weakest gate from the table above;
• the one official requirement most likely to block submission;
• the alternative venue to keep warm if the first-choice fit fails.

Output format

[Top journal skill] <skill-name>
[Alt 1] <skill-name> (reason)
[Alt 2] <skill-name> (reason)
[Do not submit to] <journal> (one-line mismatch reason)
[Evidence gates] contribution / evidence-strength / scale / deposition / compliance: pass|watch|block
[Biggest current gap] significance / field-evidence / replication / data-deposition / scale-framing / official requirements
[Claim to narrow] <claim, or none>
[Next step] invoke <skill-name> for single-venue fit and re-framing